Enterprise

ClearSky lights up Clearwater Beach Resort with multi-operator Small Cells

Shephards Beach Resort BeachPrestigious hotel resort complexes need to deliver 21st Century wireless service. Neutral host provider ClearSky Technologies employed a novel technique to raise service levels for all guests and employees, regardless of which host network operator they subscribe to. Clearwater resort General Manager Paul Andrews shared his perspective on the project and what it means for his guests, employees and business.

 

Shephards Beach Resort Skyview

A venerable institution

Originally built in 1959 in the Clearwater Beach area of Western Florida, this extensive hotel resort has been expanded and refurbished substantially over the years to host a wide range of clientele. Their customer mix includes everything from business meetings, family holidays, beach holidays to snowbirds and weddings. Stay duration ranges from 1 night to over 3 months, averaging 5.5 days. Paul describes the resort as a “Cruise ship on land”.

It’s certainly successful with an average occupancy rate of over 80%. The complex includes two separate six storey buildings (one with the original iron framework), beachfront, sound stage, restaurants, bars and accommodation.

How has cellular usage evolved?

I’ve witnessed a gradual change. We noticed as the years have gone by that now everybody is now using a cellphone, and also using it constantly. We had noticed that some attending business meetings would leave the room to make a call – it wasn’t only for privacy or etiquette reasons but more often because calls would drop or fail. Our own staff couldn’t use their phones in some parts of the resort at all.

This wasn’t specific to any single network operator. We saw it more with Verizon and AT&T perhaps because those tend to have more business customers. While we do have a free to use Wi-Fi throughout the resort, this just isn’t the same as regular cellphone service.

We hold concerts on a large outdoor stage almost every night. Nowadays many guests take videos of the band or of the dancing and want to share those with their friends. However, there was a canyon effect with neighbour buildings which restricted service in the outdoor beach area.

In the past this had led to some social media comments which compared unfavourably with the positive experience of the rest of our facilities.

Shephards Beach Markup 

Who did you approach to resolve the problem?

We have a cellular company contract for our managers cellphones with one network provider. About three years ago, we asked for help and they supplied us with a booster which had no effect, so we sent it back.

Even if this had worked, it would only have addressed the problem for those on that network. We have other staff using different providers and our guests use all of the national networks.

Rather than dealing with each of the network operators directly, we worked with ClearSky as our single point of contact to install their FORTÉ multi-operator small cell system. They liaised with all the operators behind the scenes on our behalf.

How quickly was the system installed?

It was around six weeks from start to finish. They first explained the whole process to me, then made a thorough site inspection to identify all of the locations with poor service. Wiring installation took about three weeks, spanning two buildings, six floors involving restaurants, bars and outside areas. This was done during the daytime with little inconvenience and no disruption to our normal business. Service commissioning was rapid and I’ve been very impressed with project execution.

 Shephards Beach Hallway Install

ClearSky used their NetView 360 tool to analyse the site coverage and quickly identify the number and placement of each small cell. Only around 100,000 sq feet of the total 150,000 sq feet area needed to be enhanced. iBwave’s in-building design tool was used to document and share a 3D plan with all network operators and the installation team. Each operator had a slightly different design to accommodate their existing coverage, level of usage, spectrum choice and their own design preferences. This meant that the small cells were spread out and rarely needed to be co-located for multiple operators. The equipment was a mix of 3G to fill coverage holes and widespread use of LTE technology.

Separate SpiderCloud E-RANs were installed for each of Verizon and AT&T, both with dual carrier LTE. T-Mobile was supported by Nokia Flexizone equipment, while Sprint was served via Commscope’s S1000 Enterprise Femtocells with time synchronisation from a Microsemi iGM1100. Sprint had adequate voice coverage using 3G.

We already had fibre to the property for our landline phone and Wi-Fi services so that just needed a straightforward capacity upgrade. Many hotels of our size have upgraded from 100Mbps to 200Mbps in the past year, so this isn’t unusual.

 Shephards Beach Network Diagram

How do you measure its success?

Three specific points come to mind

  1. All our employees can communicate using their cellphones, even in the difficult areas around the food/beverage storage (with many electrically noisy refrigeration coolers) and on the second floor.
  2. Guests in the meeting rooms no longer have to step outside to use their cellphones
  3. Social media comments from guests about poor cellular service have subsided

I’ve also noticed that almost all our employees now rely on their own cellphones to keep in touch throughout the resort. We do have a private paging system and walky-talky wireless which is now only rarely used.

With good in-building cellular service, the use of our free resort Wi-Fi has reduced from around 200-300 concurrent users down to around 100 at peak times. I think this is also partly driven by the move to large or unlimited data plans for many smartphone users who then just choose the easiest option. There’s little financial incentive to use Wi-Fi except for our international guests.

Any problems so far?

We continue to deal with ClearSky as our first point of support. To date, we’ve only made one support call which quickly reset a node to full service. They’ve not yet needed to visit onsite but would do so when required.

I have no doubt that cellphone technology will continue to evolve and there will be some minor upgrades in due course, but I’m confident that the solution we have should meet our needs for some years to come.

Good in-building cellular service has become an essential  part of the hospitality package today. Any hotel without it will be seriously disadvantaged unless they are marketing a “cellular detox” package.

Shephards Beach Main Tower from the Beach 

Hits : 2298

Comments   

#1 Steve said: 
David,

no mention of how the small cell approach compares in cost to the neutral DAS approach. Looks like quite a bit more hardware was used and there is mention of weeks of internal wiring. One would hope that small cell approach would rely more on wireless building penetration and less on hard wire as required by DAS. No mention of Public Safety, which is often aggregated with DAS as well. Any idea of final cost of neutral small cell versus DAS? We all understand that every hotel is a candidate, but most operators still believe it is up to the Carriers to pay for better service.

Cheers,

Steve Collin, Las Vegas
0 Quote 2017-05-16 17:39
 
#2 Graham Payne said: 
Congratulations ClearSky on achieving this (hope the calls we had last year helped).
On the points on cabling and cost the small cell solution uses structured cabling and is significantly easier and lower cost than alternatives. Then the amount of equipment isn't that much more by using a cell per Operator as each needs many for capacity anyway. The result is a significantly lower cost solution than traditional DAS. In the UK with OpenCell we now have 5 hotels including 5 star prime London Hotels live using a similar method. The benefits for many businesses now outweigh the costs and so it makes good business sense to fund the deployment if the mobile operators won't.
+1 Quote 2017-05-16 20:38
 
#3 Dean Fresonke said: 
I'm writing in on behalf of ClearSky and happy to answer questions from Steve. However, Graham already did a spot on job in responding to most points. The OpenCell team are true leaders in multi-operator enterprise-clas s small cells.

Regarding Steve's question on time required for wiring, that was a function of coordinating the four operators on this first of its kind deployment and we ended up hanging their small cells at different times. The wiring is all Cat 5 and was done all at once over a 4 day period. Costs are as good or better than DAS but the key differentiator is the small cell is the radio source. So no more installing a DAS and waiting for operator participation. When the system goes in, you're up on all operators.
Regards,
Dean Fresonke
0 Quote 2017-05-25 23:58
 
  • 4

    more

    Residential

    Residential

    A significant number of users continue to report poor mobile coverage in their homes. There will always be areas which are uneconomic for mobile operator to reach. They range from rural areas

    ...
  • 4

    more

    Enterprise

    Enterprise

    The term Enterprise addresses any non-residential in-building including hotels, convention centres, transport hubs, offices, hospitals and retail outlets. It's not just intended for businesses to

    ...
  • 4

    more

    Urban

    Urban

    Urban small cells (sometimes also named metrocells) are compact and discrete mobile phone basestations, unobstrusively located in urban areas. They can be mounted on lampposts, positioned on the

    ...
  • 4

    more

    Rural

    Rural

    A rural small cell is a low power mobile phone base station designed to bring mobile phone service to small pockets of population in remote rural areas. These could be hamlets, small villages or

    ...
Categories
Backhaul Timing and Sync Chipsets Wi-Fi LTE TDD Regional

Popular Categories

Follow us on...

footer-logo

Search